Selecting the Suitable Tunnel Supporting System Using an Integrated Decision Support System, (Case Study: Dolaei Tunnel of Touyserkan, Iran)

Document Type : Regular Article


1 M.Sc. Student of Civil Engineering, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Calabria, Rende, Italy

2 Associate Professor of Mining Engineering, Faculty of Mining and Metallurgical Engineering, Urmia University of Technology (UUT), Urmia, Iran

3 Assistant Professor of Industrial Engineering, Faculty of Industrial Engineering, Urmia University of Technology (UUT), Urmia, Iran

4 Department of Logistics, Tourism, and Service Management, Faculty of Business and Economics, German University of Technology (GUtech), Muscat, Oman

5 Assistant Professor of Mining Engineering, Faculty of Mining and Metallurgical Engineering, Urmia University of Technology (UUT), Urmia, Iran


The main goal of this study is the selection of an appropriate tunnel supporting system according to the combination of FDAHP method (Fuzzy Delphi Analytic Hierarchy Process) and ELECTRE (Elimination and Choice Expressing Reality) technique. This integrated decision support system provides useful support for selecting a tunnel supporting system. The weights of the criteria was determined by FDAHP method, and a suitable tunnel supporting system for Dolaei tunnel of Touyserkan in Iran was determined by the ELECTRE. The study was supported by the results obtained from a questionnaire carried out to understand the opinions of experts in this subject. According to surveys in this regard, six significant criteria and five alternatives such as reinforced shotcrete, metal frames, concrete prefabricated segments, in situ reinforced concrete implementation, rock bolt and reinforced shotcrete implementation have been examined. The obtained results showed that the rock bolt with reinforced shotcrete supporting system is the most suitable.


Google Scholar


Main Subjects

[1]     Haghshenas SS, Haghshenas SS, Barmal M, Farzan N. Utilization of soft computing for risk assessment of a tunneling project using geological units. Civ Eng J 2016;2:358–64.
[2]     Salemi A, Mikaeil R, Haghshenas SS. Integration of Finite Difference Method and Genetic Algorithm to Seismic analysis of Circular Shallow Tunnels (Case Study: Tabriz Urban Railway Tunnels). KSCE J Civ Eng 2018;22:1978–90. doi:10.1007/s12205-017-2039-y.
[3]     Haghshenas SS, Haghshenas SS, Mikaeil R, Ardalan T, Sedaghati Z, Kazemzadeh Heris P. Selection of an Appropriate Tunnel Boring Machine Using TOPSIS-FDAHP Method (Case Study: Line 7 of Tehran Subway, East-West Section). Electron J Geotech Eng 2017;22:4047–62.
[4]     Mikaeil R, Shaffiee Haghshenas S, Shirvand Y, Valizadeh Hasanluy M, Roshanaei V. Risk Assessment of Geological Hazards in a Tunneling Project Using Harmony Search Algorithm (Case Study: Ardabil-Mianeh Railway Tunnel). Civ Eng J 2016;2:546–54. doi:10.28991/cej-2016-00000057.
[5]     Mikaeil R, Shaffiee Haghshenas S, Sedaghati Z. Geotechnical risk evaluation of tunneling projects using optimization techniques (case study: the second part of Emamzade Hashem tunnel). Nat Hazards 2019;97:1099–113. doi:10.1007/s11069-019-03688-z.
[7]     Mikaeil R, Beigmohammadi M, Bakhtavar E, Haghshenas SS. Assessment of risks of tunneling project in Iran using artificial bee colony algorithm. SN Appl Sci 2019;1:1711. doi:10.1007/s42452-019-1749-9.
[8]     Esmailzadeh A, Shirzad PJ, Haghshenas SS. Technical analysis of collapse in tunnel excavation and suggestion of preventing appropriate applicable methods (case study: sardasht dam second diversion tunnel). Civ Eng J 2017;3:682–9.
[9]     Tehrani K. Geology of Iran. Publications of Payam Noor University, Tehran, Iran 1996.
[10]    Nazari S. Dolaei tunnel geological report. Shahied Rajaeei Institute. Tehran, Iran. 2003.
[11]    Nazari SM., Amiri R, Kolivand A. Evaluation of various factors in the loss Dolaei Access Tunnel of Tuyserkan City. 6th Natl Conf Tunnel Tehran, Iran 2004.
[12]    Saaty TL. The Analytic Hierarchy Process Mcgraw Hill, New York. Agric Econ Rev 1980;70.
[13]    Kahraman C, Ruan D, Doǧan I. Fuzzy group decision-making for facility location selection. Inf Sci (Ny) 2003;157:135–53. doi:10.1016/S0020-0255(03)00183-X.
[14]    Wang T-C, Chen Y-H. Applying consistent fuzzy preference relations to partnership selection. Omega 2007;35:384–8. doi:10.1016/
[15]    Deng H. Multicriteria analysis with fuzzy pairwise comparison. Int J Approx Reason 1999;21:215–31. doi:10.1016/S0888-613X(99)00025-0.
[16]    Analysis of Protection of Body Slope in the Rockfill Reservoir Dams on the Basis of Fuzzy Logic. Proc 4th Int Jt Conf Comput Intell, SciTePress - Science and and Technology Publications; 2012, p. 367–73. doi:10.5220/0004153803670373.
[17]    Shafiee Haghshenas S, Mikaeil R, Shaffiee Haghshenas S, Zare Naghadehi M, Sirati Moghadam P. Fuzzy and Classical MCDM Techniques to Rank the Slope Stabilization Methods in a Rock-Fill Reservoir Dam. Civ Eng J 2017;3:382–94. doi:10.28991/cej-2017-00000099.
[18]    Mikaeil R, Haghshenas SS, Hoseinie SH. Rock Penetrability Classification Using Artificial Bee Colony (ABC) Algorithm and Self-Organizing Map. Geotech Geol Eng 2017. doi:10.1007/s10706-017-0394-6.
[19]    Mikaeil R, Haghshenas SS, Haghshenas SS, Ataei M. Performance prediction of circular saw machine using imperialist competitive algorithm and fuzzy clustering technique. Neural Comput Appl 2018;29:283–92. doi:10.1007/s00521-016-2557-4.
[20]    Aryafar A, Mikaeil R, Shafiee Haghshenas S. Utilization of soft computing for evaluating the performance of stone sawing machines, Iranian Quarries. Int J Min Geo-Engineering 2018;52:31–6.
[21]    Mohammadi J, Ataei M, Kakaei RK, Mikaeil R, Haghshenas SS. Prediction of the production rate of chain saw machine using the multilayer perceptron (MLP) neural network. Civ Eng J 2018;4:1575–83.
[22]    Shirani Faradonbeh R, Shaffiee Haghshenas S, Taheri A, Mikaeil R. Application of self-organizing map and fuzzy c-mean techniques for rockburst clustering in deep underground projects. Neural Comput Appl 2019. doi:10.1007/s00521-019-04353-z.
[23]    Shaffiee Haghshenas S, Shirani Faradonbeh R, Mikaeil R, Haghshenas SS, Taheri A, Saghatforoush A, et al. A new conventional criterion for the performance evaluation of gang saw machines. Measurement 2019;146:159–70. doi:10.1016/j.measurement.2019.06.031.
[24]    Dormishi A, Ataei M, Mikaeil R, Khalokakaei R, Haghshenas SS. Evaluation of gang saws’ performance in the carbonate rock cutting process using feasibility of intelligent approaches. Eng Sci Technol an Int J 2019;22:990–1000. doi:10.1016/j.jestch.2019.01.007.
[25]    Naderpour H, Mirrashid M. Shear Failure Capacity Prediction of Concrete Beam–Column Joints in Terms of ANFIS and GMDH. Pract Period Struct Des Constr 2019;24:04019006. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)SC.1943-5576.0000417.
[26]    Naderpour H, Mirrashid M. Moment capacity estimation of spirally reinforced concrete columns using ANFIS. Complex Intell Syst 2019. doi:10.1007/s40747-019-00118-2.
[27]    Sari PA, Suhatril M, Osman N, Mu’azu MA, Dehghani H, Sedghi Y, et al. An intelligent based-model role to simulate the factor of safe slope by support vector regression. Eng Comput 2019;35:1521–31. doi:10.1007/s00366-018-0677-4.
[28]    Koopialipoor M, Fahimifar A, Ghaleini EN, Momenzadeh M, Armaghani DJ. Development of a new hybrid ANN for solving a geotechnical problem related to tunnel boring machine performance. Eng Comput 2020;36:345–57. doi:10.1007/s00366-019-00701-8.
[29]    Cheng J-H, Tang C-H. An application of fuzzy Delphi and fuzzy AHP for multi-criteria evaluation on bicycle industry supply chains. WSEAS Trans Syst Control 2009;4:21–34.
[30]    Mikaeil R, Ataei M, Yousefi R. Evaluating the power consumption in carbonate rock sawing porocess by using FDAHP and TOPSIS techniques. Effic Decis Support Syst Challenges Multidiscip Domains 2011:413–36.
[31]    Mikaeil R, Ozcelik Y, Yousefi R, Ataei M, Mehdi Hosseini S. Ranking the sawability of ornamental stone using Fuzzy Delphi and multi-criteria decision-making techniques. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2013;58:118–26. doi:10.1016/j.ijrmms.2012.09.002.
[32]    Roy B. Classement et choix en présence de points de vue multiples. Rev Française d’informatique Rech Opérationnelle 1968;2:57–75.
[33]    Shanian A, Savadogo O. ELECTRE I decision support model for material selection of bipolar plates for Polymer Electrolyte Fuel Cells applications. J New Mater Electrochem Syst 2006;9:191.
[34]    Huang W-C, Chen C-H. Using the ELECTRE II method to apply and analyze the differentiation theory. Proc East Asia Soc Transp Stud, vol. 5, 2005, p. 2237–49.
[35]    Collette Y, Siarry P. Multiobjective optimization: principles and case studies. Springer Science & Business Media; 2013.
[36]    Rogers M, Bruen M, Maystre L-Y. ELECTRE and Decision Support. Boston, MA: Springer US; 2000. doi:10.1007/978-1-4757-5057-7.
[37]    Delft A, Nijkamp P. A multi-objective decision model for regional development, environmental quality control and industrial land use. Pap Reg Sci 2005;36:35–58. doi:10.1111/j.1435-5597.1976.tb00957.x.
[38]    Milani AS, Shanian A, El-Lahham C. Using different ELECTRE methods in strategic planning in the presence of human behavioral resistance. J Appl Math Decis Sci 2006;2006:1–19. doi:10.1155/JAMDS/2006/10936.
[39]    Ghasemi L, Bahlol B, F T. The relationship between microscopic structure and mechanical behavior of the Alvand aureole rocks and its effect on duplex stability Tuyserkan tunnel. 5th Int Conf Eng Geol Environ Tehran, Iran 2004:895–904.
[40]    National Geoscience Database of Iran. General geology and structural units of Iran, geological map of Iran (1:1000.000 scale). n.d.
[41]    Jalilvand P, Haghshenas SS, Haghshenas SS, Javan MH. Evaluation of Dynamic Resistance of the Toyserkan Doolayi Tunnel by Rock Bolt and Reinforced Shotcrete Composite System. Tunneling Undergr Constr, Reston, VA: American Society of Civil Engineers; 2014, p. 376–84. doi:10.1061/9780784413449.037.
[42]    Jalilvand P, Haghshenas SS. The study stability of Toyserkan Doolayi Tunnel using reinforces shotcrete and rock bolt under static condition. 23rd Int Min Congr Exhib Turkey, 2013, p. 1299–305.
[43]    Haghshenas SS, Ozcelik Y, Haghshenas SS, Mikaeil R, Moghadam PS. Ranking and assessment of tunneling projects risks using fuzzy MCDM (Case study: Toyserkan doolayi tunnel). 25th Int Min Congr Exhib Turkey, 2017, p. 289–97.